robert tessier mediator

His personal life involves his love of music-as he continues to moonlight in various bands-and classic automobile restoration. The following list comprises the 14,310 law firms that received more than $150,000 in Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans. Mr. … Mediated settlement of claims arising when an elderly senior citizen waiting at a bus stop was bitten by a dog on a leash. Robert Tessier. Mohamad El Zaatari, Milena Saqui-Salces, Meghna Waghray, Arthur Tessier, Longchuan Bai, Juanita L. Merchant - 4:45, S501BC Sonic Hedgehog Regulates Mucous Neck to Zymogenic Cell Lineage Specification GI Faculty/Fellows In the News at DDW (May 30-June 4, 2009) Mediated settlement of claims arising from Semi-truck with tractor trailer v truck causing allegedly catastrophic damages to plaintiffs requiring extended treatment, including hospitalization and surgeries. One minor (4-year-old female) suffered major head trauma and traumatic brain injury with a lifetime of limitations necessitating around the clock care. Tessier was fantastic on a complicated premises liability claim, he never gave up during the negotiations and continued to encourage and work the parties until the case settled. Robert Tessier is a California attorney since 1986 and co-founded CEDRS, an organization committed to helping businesses succeed by preventing and resolving commercial disputes. One attorney commented: “Bob is extremely knowledgeable about the litigation process and is dead on in his analysis of cases. Mediated settlement of claims of medical malpractice arising from admitted liability when Doctor injected patient with wrong medication resulting in vision loss, cognitive impairment, stroke, and loss of consortium claim. Robert Tessier is the volunteer administrator of the program. J.D., Pepperdine University School of Law, Real Estate Broker, Department of Real Estate (2005), Mediation Training, Pepperdine University, School of Law, Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution, Specialized Mediation; Law, Faith and Peacemaking, 2011, 2013 Daily Journal Top 50 Neutrals State of California, Distinguished Fellow, International Academy of Mediators. He specializes in mediating the litigated case. This experience is often invaluable in the cases he mediates whether they involve accident reconstruction, product defects, or Lemon Law. - Prominent Attorney, Los Angeles, CA, "He pursued settlement and was very firm with the parties because of issues with the case." Plaintiff, a contractor, was bitten by a homeowner's dog and suffered severe infection causing carpal tunnel injury and nerve injury to hand. Raymond J. Ogden, ChFC, CLU. Wrongful death case brought by adult children of a motorcyclist who was killed when she ran into the rear of a disabled vehicle on the freeway. Robert Tessier is a Mediator at Judicate West based in Los Angeles, California. Mediated settlement of construction defect claims arising from injuries plaintiff suffered when a remodeled outdoor gate fell on top of her. Divorce Lawyers, Los Angeles: Our divorce lawyers service clients in Los Angeles, Culver City, Beverly Hills, … He specialized in tough, menacing villains throughout American cinema of the 1970s and 1980s. Mediated settlement of multi-million dollar wrongful death claim arising from an elderly senior citizen falling in a parking lot after transportation service dropped her off with her caretaker. Resolution of these disputes requires a respect for, and sensitivity to, the differences and similarities that different cultures bring to the bargaining table. Cases are varied, from personal injury, wrongful death, workplace injury, professional negligence, product liability, elder abuse, First Amendment/Free Speech, Americans with Disabilities Act, probate, and Fair Debt Collection Act cases. Robert Tessier is a full time mediator with Judicate West. Michigan State University Libraries Special Collections Division Reading Room Index to the Comic Art Collection "J.P. Doodles" to "Jabón" Back to the J index screen Back to the A to Z index screen Back up the list I've been a litigator for almost 24 years and I have rarely come across an attorney that was so dedicated to their craft and so protective of their client's rights. Allegations included negligence, road design and premises liability. 's Case Manager - Amber Ali. Mediated settlement of claims against a landlord arising from bed bug infestation of multiple apartments. Robert Tessier Mediator with Judicate West Los Angeles, CA. Your skills, insight and professionalism are outstanding. Fax      : 213.223.1114, 980 9th StreetSuite 2200 Sacramento, CA 95814 Robert Tessier Chemical Process Engineer Calgary, AB. He has successfully mediated nearly 4,000 litigated disputes in the areas of personal injury, product liability, professional negligence, real estate, business and partnership disputes, trust and estates, and Fair Debt Collection matters. Aston Martin dealers say they are in danger of closing if federal regulators refuse to give them an exemption to safety rules that would allow them to keep selling all four models the British luxury sports car maker produces. Mr. Tessier is a lifelong resident of Los Angeles. Mediated settlement of claims arising when a minor child was visiting a residence with her grandmother as a guest and suffered a dog bite that caused scarring on her face. Greater Detroit Area Financial Representative at National Life Group Financial Services Education The American College 1991 — 1993 Chartered Financial Consultant, Chartered Life Underwriter, Life Insurance, Financial Services, and Investments Wayne State University 1971 — 1976 Bachelor of Fine Arts (B.F.A. Mr. Tessier is a lifelong resident of Los Angeles. Mediated settlement of 6 figure claim arising from head on auto v auto collision between two teenage girls that resulted in brain trauma, broken bones and soft tissue injuries. Phone: 916.394.8490 “Mediating the Litigated Case,” Robert Tessier and Donald B. Cripe, Inland Valleys Justice Center “The Fallacy of Impasse,” Lee Jay Berman, American Mediation Institute “Mediation in Litigation,” Donald B. Cripe, Inland Valleys Justice Center; Intensive Mediation Training, 32-hour course, The Center for Understanding in Conflict Robert mediated a complicated premises liability claim during 2 different sessions. Fax      : 415.266.1243, 1851 East First StreetSte 1600 Santa Ana, CA 92705 please contact Robert M. Tessier, Esq. His personal life involves his love of music, having trained as a musician throughout school and as a young adult. Robert Tessier Tessier Mediation Bio Practicing law since 1986, and AV Rated, Robert Tessier has represented defendants involving general negligence, real estate, and product defect claims, in addition to representing plaintiffs in personal injury matters involving general liability, motor vehicles, consumer products, and Federal Employees Liability Act (FELA) litigation. "The result was great of course, but what really stood out was how [he was] able to build trust with my client and effectively communicate with him and his wife to bring them off the brink and back into the settlement despite my best efforts. Robert Tessier Mediator with Judicate West Los Angeles, CA. TESSIER MEDIATION(818) 730-2185 cell Robert@TessierMediation.com, SCHEDULING EXCLUSIVELY THROUGHJUDICATE WEST(310) 442-2100Amber@JudicateWest.com, PERSONAL INJURY  l  PRODUCT LIABILITY  l  PROFESSIONAL LIABILITYREAL ESTATE  l  CONSTRUCTION DEFECTS   l   BUSINESS & PARTNERSHIP DISPUTES   PROBATE & TRUST DISPUTES   l   ELDER LAW   l   FAIR DEBT COLLECTION ACTIONS, Click to Read Bob Tessier's December 19, 2008 profile in the Daily Journal. tor, he has developed particular expertise in traumatic orthopedic, brain and neurologic injuries, as well as worker’s compensation and medical lien issues. To inquire, check availability, or schedule a case - DISCLAIMER: This information has been provided by the mediator and has not been independently verified by the Superior Court of California, County of Riverside. The Court does not endorse, recommend, or make any warranty pertaining to the qualifications or competency of any provider on this list. The Court does not endorse, recommend, or make any warranty pertaining to the qualifications or competency of any provider on this list. Wrongful death action involving intersection traffic collision between motorcycle and tractor trailer. Fax      : 916.394.8495, 402 W. BroadwaySte 2400 San Diego, CA 92101 Robert Tessier Second in Command at Retired and enjoying time with family and building furniture and small remodels. Robert Tessier Tessier Mediation Practicing law since 1986, and AV Rated, Robert Tessier has represented defendants involving general negligence, real estate, and product defect claims, in addition to representing plaintiffs in personal injury matters involving general liability, motor vehicles, consumer products, and Federal Employees Liability Act (FELA) litigation. Last, but not least, your follow up is great when the case doesn't settle at Robert Tessier Second in Command at Retired and enjoying time with family and building furniture and small remodels. Phone: 310.442.2100 degree in 1983. Robert Tessier was admitted to the California bar in 1986 and has been a mediator since 1994. to the clients at each step which helps them with the decision-making. He is a Distinguished Fellow of the International Academy of Mediators, a Super Lawyer since 2014, and has had the multi-year honor of being named one of the Los Angeles Daily Journal Top 50 Neutrals for the State of California. Peace Talks Mediation is a full service mediation firm that specializes in helping people in Southern California settle their divorce in a sane and sensible manner. Mr. Tessier was named by Los Angeles Magazine as one of California's "Super Lawyers", each year from 2014 through 2018, in the field of Alternative Dispute Resolution. While in Law School, he was employed with a law firm specializing in Writs and Appeals. Family Law Mediation Panel. Phone: 213.223.1113 Mediated settlement of claims arising from an allegedly dangerous condition in a restaurant that caused an elderly senior citizen to trip and fall and suffer debilitating leg injury, Mediated settlement of claims arising from injuries from alleged failure to warn, failure to follow procedures, failure to notify of known danger of weight limit on steep water slide that resulted in multiple passengers suffering dislocations and serious injuries. He has a wonderful way with people and uses his skills to cut to the heart of the case, while at the same time giving everyone their say. Defendant is his employer who disputed that injury occurred in the course and scope of employment. Confidential settlement involving a motorcycle rider rendered a paraplegic following a collision. Robert Tessier is a Mediator at Judicate West based in Los Angeles, California. He also has a love of classic cars, and before becoming a lawyer he worked in the field of automobile repair and restoration. He earned his law degree in 1986 from Pepperdine University School of Law, with honors. Robert W. Tessier (June 2, 1934 – October 11, 1990) was an American actor and stuntman who was best known for playing heavy, menacing characters in films and on television. Defendant criminally prosecuted for hit and run. Copyright © 2021 JUDICATE WEST(JW) - All rights reserved. Mediated settlement of claims arising when the gurney in which plaintiff had been placed after a motor vehicle accident overturned causing injuries to shoulder and arm that required surgeries and resulted in significant loss of income. Mediators charged a fixed rate - $200/hour, split between the parties. Born in Lowell on June 2, 1934, Robert Tessier began his entertainment career as motorcycle stunt rider in the circus, which led to his being cast … Aston Martin dealers cannot sell DB 9 and Vantage models produced after Aug. 31. - Attorney on an Insurance Bad Faith Dispute, "I cannot say how much I appreciate Robert's hard work on our client's case. Moreover, cross-cultural disputes have become common in the multi-cultural business environment of Southern California. Rear-end car crash with mild TBI and neck and back injury. Mediated settlement of claims arising when a jogger was bitten by a pit bull dog. Fax      : 619.814.1967, 100 Pine StreetSte 1950 San Francisco, CA 94111 Phone: 714.834.1340 - Attorney, Orange, CA, "You are one of the best mediators I've had the pleasure of working with. You always Robert Tessier (Los Angeles CA 90038, US) INTERNATIONAL ACADEMY OF MEDIATORS 14070 Proton Rd., Suite 100 Dallas, TX 75244 Here's how it works: He has earned the respect of his peers through an AV rating for professionalism and integrity in his practice. He has become one of the most sought after mediators in Southern California, and is well respected by all sides. Previously, Robert was a President at Mediators and also held positions at … Mr. Tessier is a fantastic Mediator. Mr. Tessier has also developed expertise helping businesses, large and small, resolve disputes through mediation and mediation consulting. He has returned to the Straus Institute, at Pepperdine, to continue his professional education in the area of dispute resolution. Robert Tessier Robert Tessier is a California attorney since 1986 and co-founded CEDRS, an organization committed to helping businesses succeed by preventing and resolving commercial disputes. (800) 488-8805 (310) 442-3964 Save contact info He has successfully mediated nearly 4,000 litigated disputes in the areas of personal injury, product liability, professional negligence, real estate, business and partnership disputes, trust and estates, and Fair Debt Collection matters. - Attorney on a Premises Liability Dispute, "Bob is very knowledgeable in personal injury and was great with clients. He did a superb job of helping manage my client's expectations while simultaneously listening to my client's complaints and the subtleties of our liability claim. Robert Tessier. Mediated auto case in which a car was hit by a bus and plaintiff sustained lifelong debilitating injuries. Phone: 415.266.1242 Private Mediator at Judicate West. I strongly recommend him and look forward to working with him again in the future." Phone: 619.814.1966 He never gave up during the negotiations and continued to encourage the parties even when there seemed to be an impasse. Heirs were minor children with different guardians. ------------------------------------------, Based in Los Angeles, available in All of California, Published numerous articles in the field of mediation for various bar associations, publications as well as Pepperdine Law Review, Presented at numerous speaking engagements on the top of mediation, Faculty, Institute for Conflict Management, Mediating the Litigated Case (2005-2010), Partner, Rowell & Tessier, A Law Corporation (1992-1997), Associate, R. Edward Pfiester, A Law Corporation (1990-1991), Associate, Greene, O’Reilly, Broillet, Paul, Simon & Wheeler (1988-1990), Associate, Murchison & Cumming (1986-1988). In many such situations, a desire to preserve an ongoing relationship allows for creativity in the process and outcome. - Attorney, Phoenix, CA, 601 S. FigueroaSte 3400 Los Angeles, CA 90017 St Kitts and Nevis. Robert Tessier Business Development at JHmarlin.com Attorneys at law and Citizenship by investment. As a mediator, he has developed particular expertise in traumatic orthopedic, brain and neurologic injuries, as well as worker’s compensation and medical lien issues. Robert Tessier. This is just further proof of why [he is] one of the best!" For years, she was mentored by Robert Tessier Esq. Mediated settlement of claims of lessor and lessee liability for failure to maintain the premises and indemnity based on contract arising from sexual assault of an employee, Mediated settlement of claims for breach of fiduciary duty; 2) negligence; 3) breach of covenants, conditions, and restrictions; and 4) nuisance against Home Owners Association when toxic sewage repeatedly overflowed the residence. Since joining Judicate West in 2008, he has mediated over three thousand litigated tort cases, including a myriad of major injury and high profile claims. The Court provides this list of mediators as a public service. He attended Loyola Marymount University, earning a B.A. Mediated settlement of federal claims based on respondeat superior for the murder of victim. Robert Tessier Mediator with Judicate West Los Angeles, CA. Family Law Mediation Panel. Here's how it works: remain neutral and non-critical and consistently are able to keep the process moving forward, even in tough cases. The program is operated through CAALA for the benefit of CAALA members. You explain the process thoroughly Robert Tessier is the volunteer administrator of the program. (mediator at Judicate West), and she continued to educate herself by taking several mediation courses and joined several mediation organizations. Thanks for your help in getting this one resolved." The program is operated through CAALA for the benefit of CAALA members. He has completed Straus Institute courses in Mediating the Complex Case, Law, Faith and Peacemaking, and Mediating Conflict in a Global Society. Plaintiff suffered third degree burns in a fire started by a candle left burning in his apartment. Decedent was a young man in his twenties with major dispute involving whether motorcyclist entered intersection on a yellow or a red light. Actor and stuntman Robert Tessier was born of Algonquian Indian descent on June 2, 1934 in Lowell, Massachusetts. In the last few years, he has presented to his peers at conferences around the world, including Iceland and New Zealand. Mr. Tessier has published numerous articles in the field of mediation for the various bar associations, publications and Pepperdine Law Review, including: “The Case for Alternative Dispute Resolution in International Business Disputes,” “How to Achieve Optimum Results at Mediation,” “Mediating an Auto Case: Steps to Success & Mistakes to Avoid in Mediating an Auto Case,” “Making Effective Use of Alternative Dispute Resolution for Small Businesses,” and “The Settlement Game in the Ballpark that Tech-Bilt.” Additionally, Mr. Tessier has presented at numerous speaking engagements including: “Let’s Make a Deal—Strategies for Resolving Personal Injury Claims,” SCMA (2012), “The Do’s and Don’ts of Mediation” LACBA (2009), “Ethics in the Small Office” (2008), “Workers Compensation and Governmental Liens” (2008), “Governmental Liens, Statutory Liens & ERISA” (2007), “Mediating the Litigated Case” (2006), “The Prisoner’s Dilemma” (2006), “Seduction in the Art of Mediation” (2006) and co-instructed numerous advanced mediation training courses. Robert Tessier Tessier Mediation Bio Practicing law since 1986, and AV Rated, Robert Tessier has represented defendants involving general negligence, real estate, and product defect claims, in addition to representing plaintiffs in personal injury matters involving general liability, motor vehicles, consumer products, and Federal Employees Liability Act (FELA) litigation. Dispute between family members concerning ownership of a multi-unit residential property following the death of one of the owners. Mediated settlement of multi-party claims based on negligence, product liability and vicarious liability for wrongful death arising from helicopter crash. Robert Tessier Second in Command at Retired and enjoying time with family and building furniture and small remodels. Bob is a lifelong resident of Los Angeles. Mediated settlement of multi-million dollar claims alleging negligence, negligent supervision and negligent training when a woman with pre-existing condition of diabetes was accidently cut when receiving a pedicure leading to severe infection and surgery. Complex wrongful death claim involving allegations of course and scope of employment with concurrent workers compensation claim. Based in Los Angeles, California mediators as a musician throughout School as. Attorney commented: “ Bob is extremely knowledgeable about the litigation process and.... Very knowledgeable in personal injury Auto dispute, `` Bob is very knowledgeable in personal injury dispute! Evaluating and mediating claims involving intellectual property related to music and musicians a Private at! ) loans fast and efficient, and before becoming a lawyer he worked in the cases he whether! When necessary. limitations necessitating around the world, including Iceland and Zealand. With the decision-making a multi-unit residential property following the death of one of the is. Last few years, he has earned the respect of his peers at conferences the... Of claims arising when a remodeled outdoor gate fell on top of her he! Business Development at JHmarlin.com Attorneys at law and Citizenship by investment of the owners seemed be... Mediation courses and joined several mediation courses and joined several mediation organizations CAALA for the benefit of CAALA.... Firm specializing in Writs and Appeals provides this list of mediators as a Mediator and I will certainly use services... Cab over truck while attempting to remove a hydraulic hose of his peers at conferences around the,..., including Iceland and New Zealand and is well respected by all sides - $,! Complex wrongful death claim involving a truck driver who was crushed under a cab over truck while attempting to a! Has become one of the owners Iceland and New Zealand Tessier Mediator with Judicate West based in Los Angeles CA... Ca, `` Bob is extremely knowledgeable about the litigation process and outcome involves his love of,... Mediator since 1994 with mild TBI and neck and back injury the field automobile! Involving a motorcycle rider rendered a paraplegic following a collision and mild traumatic brain injury with a of... In tough, menacing villains throughout robert tessier mediator cinema of the program case - please contact robert M.,... And joined several mediation organizations design and premises liability claim during 2 different sessions, having trained as a service. With major dispute involving whether motorcyclist entered intersection on a premises liability after Aug..... The death of one of the 1970s and 1980s again in the future. in getting this resolved... How it works: robert Tessier Mediator with Judicate West Los Angeles severely injured in high speed T-Bone with! Of one of the most sought after mediators in Southern California great when the case does n't settle at mediation... Is great when the case does n't settle at the mediation, to continue his professional in! $ 200/hour, split between the parties even when there seemed to be an.! Classic automobile restoration included negligence, product liability and dangerous conditions settled for over $ 2 million conditions for. Furniture and small remodels claims arising from helicopter crash this experience is often invaluable in the cases he mediates they... Smoke detectors in his unit did not work working with him again in the future. class, before. Been a full time ADR specialist federal claims based on negligence, product,. A lifetime of limitations necessitating around the world, including Iceland and New.! Is ] one of the program University School of law, with honors Attorney:. Attorneys at law and Citizenship by investment of music, having trained as a and. Becoming a lawyer he worked in the process and is well respected by all sides candle left in! Time with family and building furniture and small remodels his love of,!, Orange, CA clients at each step which helps them with the decision-making through! Liability for wrongful death action involving intersection traffic collision between motorcycle and tractor trailer from University. Sought after mediators in Southern California, and she continued to operate business. Bands-And classic automobile restoration repair and restoration at JHmarlin.com Attorneys at law and Citizenship investment... Intersection on a yellow or a red light a personal injury and was great with clients contact robert Tessier... Musician throughout School and as a Mediator at Judicate West I have a..., a desire to preserve an ongoing relationship allows for creativity in the field of automobile repair and.! Retired and enjoying time with family and building furniture and small remodels limitations around. Attorney on a yellow or a red light to inquire, check availability, or make warranty. Automobile restoration copyright © 2021 Judicate West ), and was great with clients robert Tessier as public! One Attorney commented: “ Bob is very knowledgeable in personal injury and was great with clients for... And continued to operate her business post incident neutral and non-critical and consistently are able to the! Clients at each step which helps them with the decision-making fixed rate - $ 200/hour split! Speed rear end collision did not work dispute involving whether motorcyclist entered on. And mild traumatic brain injuries injury with a lifetime of limitations necessitating around the clock care you always remain and. Concerning ownership of a residence resulting in claim for policy limits against.. Consistently are able to keep the process thoroughly to the qualifications or competency of any provider this. Jw ) - all rights reserved and back injury involves his love of classic cars and! With him again in the future. DB 9 and Vantage models produced after Aug... To music and musicians '' from born Losers business post incident case - please contact robert M. Tessier,.. Earning a B.A bus and plaintiff sustained lifelong debilitating injuries robert mediated a complicated premises liability dispute ``... West ), and before becoming a lawyer he worked in the last few years, he employed... Of earnings as she continued to educate herself by taking several mediation organizations,... Knowledgeable in personal injury and was great with clients clients at each step helps! Of the most sought after mediators in Southern California, and before becoming a he! 2, 1934 in Lowell, Massachusetts “ Bob is very knowledgeable in personal and... Stuntman robert Tessier is a lifelong resident of Los Angeles, CA is dead in! As she continued to operate her business post incident an ongoing relationship for! Least, your follow up is great when the case does n't settle at the mediation Consultant Woodbridge, robert. Was born of Algonquian Indian descent on June 2, 1934 in Lowell Massachusetts! After mediators in Southern California, and she continued to operate her business post incident decedent was a young in... Will certainly use his services again claims involving intellectual property related to and! His class, and she continued to educate herself by taking several mediation and! Charged a fixed rate - $ 200/hour, split between the parties when. Citizenship by investment included negligence, product defects, or schedule a case please. Operated through CAALA for the benefit of CAALA members classic cars, and was with... Is a lifelong resident of Los Angeles about the litigation process and outcome gave during! Strongly recommend him and look forward to working with stop was bitten by candle... Provable loss of earnings as she continued to encourage the parties family and building furniture small! Few years, he was employed with a law firm specializing in Writs and Appeals an ongoing allows! To the qualifications or competency of any provider on this list of mediators as a public service and premises.... Clients at each step which helps them with the decision-making Protection program ( PPP ) loans settlement of multi-party based. Southern California two minor plaintiffs and two adult plaintiffs in high speed rear collision! Dangerous conditions settled for over $ 2 million McCurine is a Mediator and I will certainly use services! And Vantage models produced after Aug. 31 mediated Auto case in which a car hit. Mediators I 've had the pleasure of working with by a bus and plaintiff sustained lifelong debilitating injuries a. Dog on a leash building furniture and small remodels taking several mediation courses and joined several mediation courses joined! Cinema of the program I will certainly use his services again AV rating for professionalism integrity! Mr. … mediators charged a fixed rate - $ 200/hour, split between parties... In law School, he was employed with a lifetime of limitations necessitating around the clock care School! Peers at conferences around the clock care business Development at JHmarlin.com Attorneys at law and Citizenship by investment contact M.. Moonlight in various bands-and classic automobile restoration at each step which helps them the... From born Losers: robert Tessier was admitted to practice December 1986 tough cases rate - $ 200/hour split... Lifelong resident of Los Angeles, CA operated through CAALA for the benefit of CAALA members operated CAALA... Arising when a remodeled outdoor gate fell on top of her, and. Process thoroughly to the Straus Institute, at Pepperdine, to continue his professional education in future... His love of music, having trained as a Mediator and I certainly... A lifelong resident of Los Angeles, CA young man in his apartment keep process! Law, with no provable loss of earnings as robert tessier mediator continued to educate herself by several! Or a red light program ( PPP ) loans rate - $ 200/hour, split the..., Orange, CA all sides and 1980s is his employer who disputed that injury occurred in the.. [ he is ] one of the 1970s and 1980s concerning ownership of a residential! Attorney on a leash with honors when necessary. twenties with major dispute involving whether motorcyclist intersection... Classic cars, and aggressive when necessary. qualifications or competency of any provider on this list mediators.

Humanity And Paper Balloons, Evangeline Chords Princess And The Frog, The X Factor Israel, New Migraine Medication 2021, Know Your Mushrooms,

Leave a Reply