i trapped the devil ending

Four friends, well aware of the irony and cliche involved, visit the abandoned Carpenter Hill Hospital for fun, for laughs and for scares but none of them can know the true darkness that ... See full summary ». Showing all 3 items Jump to: Summaries (3) Summaries. The ending leads to even more frustrating lapses of illogical behavior. The problem is that the 1960 version was a tight and compact 30 minutes of entertainment, whereas writer/director Lobo struggles to expand his version of “The Howling Man” to film length. … [Indie Horror Month 2021] Ihm: Revisited – Video Interview with Actor Aj Bowen (Part One), SXSW: Yellow Veil Pictures Lands Global Sales Rights for Joe Manganiello, Lucy Lawless Animated Fantasy ‘The Spine of Night’ (Exclusive), Best Horror Movies on Hulu in October 2020, Nocturna Madrid, Festival Internacional de Cine Fantástico 2019 Oct 22-26. I Trapped the Devil Matt (AJ Bowen) and his wife Karen (Susan Burke) arrive unexpectedly to visit Matt’s brother Steve (Scott Poythress) at Christmastime. Our editors have rounded up their most anticipated horror movies of the year. He eventually convinces the monks to let him stay the night, but during his stay finds another guy trapped in a cell. For more than a decade /R/HORROR has been reddit.com's gateway to all things Horror: from movies & TV, to books & games. A man descends into paranoia after trapping what he believes to be the devil in his basement, but things take a dark turn when his family unexpectedly arrive for Christmas. I Trapped the Devil Movie Drinking Game. questions unanswered (as designed, ofc) like- how do you get satan in your basement and lock him in without him doing anything about it? But when Matt and his wife Karen show up unannounced at the home of his estranged brother Steve to celebrate the holidays, they are instead greeted with a horrifying surprise: trapped in the basement is a man. Basically at the end the cop , opens the door , and from it the "devil" come out? Not once did he care, not even now,” he said softly. Sophie and her friends must rally together to send their party crashers... See full summary ». I Trapped the Devil is an unsettling movie. A young scientist discovers a malevolent entity which sets her on a bloody descent into the jaws of insanity. Beer makes movies better. I Trapped the Devil is the debut feature for writer/director Josh Lobo, who previously worked in the art department for 2017's Dave Made a Maze; an exciting credit, as that film had wonderfully creative art design with its cardboard themed sets and creatures. I Trapped the Devil opens in limited release and hits VOD on April 26. I Trapped The Devil is not a supernatural thriller, some low budget chiller with cheesy visual effects and cheap jump scares. “Something feels wrong,” says a concerned brother early in writer and director Josh Lobo ‘s debut horror film I Trapped The Devil , and he certainly has every reason to feel so. The cast, however, is working hard and makes everything work. The efficient opening puts I Trapped the Devil in a position for great horror potential; which way will it go? Only those unfamiliar with The Twilight Zone will find anything intriguing here. I Trapped the Devil is a 2019 American supernatural horror film written, produced, edited, and directed by Josh Lobo in his feature film directorial debut. Jared Mobarak is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic for The Film Stage, Art Director for Buffalo, NY film series Cultivate Cinema Circle, and member of OFCS and GWNYFCA. The psychological horror movie is being released by IFC Midnight. Christmas is supposed to be a time for peace and joyful family reunions. But not just any man. I Trapped the Devil is a horror movie, but do be warned that it takes slow-burn to a new level. Take a drink when. Agreed. Admittedly, the ending is solid, but not quite solid enough to make up for 70 or so minutes that’s come before it. It stars A. J. Bowen, Scott Poythress, Susan Theresa Burke, Jocelin Donahue, and Chris Sullivan. Yet the background behind this film explains a lot. A murderous shapeshifter sets out on a blood-soaked mission to make things right with the woman he loves. But when Matt (Bowen) and his wife Karen (Burke) show up unannounced at the home of his estranged brother Steve (Poythress) to celebrate the holidays, they are instead greeted with a horrifying surprise: trapped in the basement is a man. Written by A plains-woman faces the harshness and isolation of the untamed land in the Western frontier of the late 1800s. A young woman finds her home plagued by mutant Rats from Outer Space. Christmas is supposed to be a time for peace and joyful family reunions. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Fascinating premise to the film and in more capable hands, might have been something really special. Padding. a girl apparently e-e. during the movies we have heard alot the voice from the other side of the door, it often suonded really MANLY and eldery , why then from it come out a girl????? Written and directed by Josh Lobo, I TRAPPED THE DEVIL slowly tortures the viewer towards what you know in your gut will not be a happy ending. The element of the surprise in the ending or for those that have never heard of The Howling Man will find this rather uneventful on first watch. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for I Trapped the Devil at Amazon.com. I absolutely adored the creepy vibe of I Trapped the Devil, but the pace was too slow for me.As in way too slow! "I Trapped The Devil" portrays the line between reality and intuition. Related Posts. lets start the discussion. Here's the good things about "I Trapped The Devil" - The atmosphere can be grim when it tries enough, the take on the devil was smart & crafty for a low-budget flick, the little twist at the ending is, in my opinion, quite cool & the performance by Scott Poythress is as good as the flawed script allows him to be. In The Howling Man a guy shows up to an old monastery begging for shelter but is turned away. In fact, I believe the only way a person would not acknowledge his existence is because of denial or deception. The devil must have crap powers these days. I Trapped the Devil (2019). Frantic to find the cash, the ... See full summary ». i appreciate the answer, anyway i probably asked opinions to late, the hype for the movie was probably gone.or simply people didn't want to answer xD. In the slow-burn horror film I Trapped the Devil, A.J. best scene of the movie "devil" when the devil is inside of an old woman's body!!! Will there be philosophical debates on the nature of evil, whether it’s even possible to contain such a force? Take a shot when. A man descends into paranoia after trapping what he believes to be the devil in his basement, but things take a dark turn when his family unexpectedly arrive for Christmas. I Trapped the Devil is the debut feature for writer/director Josh Lobo, who previously worked in the art department for 2017's Dave Made a Maze; an exciting credit, as that film had wonderfully creative art design with its cardboard themed sets and creatures. Plus it adds another present to be opened over and over for the Christmas season. In The Howling Man a guy shows up to an old monastery begging for shelter but is turned away. I Trapped The Devil is a 2019 horror film about a man who descends into paranoia after trapping what he believes to be the devil in his basement. (2019). what do you think?? I Trapped the Devil might end up feeling more like an appetizer, but it promises a helluva meal to come. The sinister Christmas movie I Trapped the Devil was released on April 26, 2019, following its debut at the Imagine Film Festival.Josh Lobo wrote, directed, and edited this 80-minute seasonal horror film that centers around Steve (Scott Poythress), a paranoid man living alone who gets an unexpected visit from his brother Matt (AJ Bown) and Matt’s wife Karen (Susan Burke) on Christmas Eve. But eventually it just becomes laughably ridiculous. It premiered at the Imagine Film Festival on April 12, 2019, and IFC Midnight released the film theatrically in the United States and simultaneously via video-on-demand platforms on April 26, 2019. While working overtime through several nights, I fell asleep for a short while. On face value, for many, it will be a lot harder to gauge. On face value, for many, it will be a lot harder to gauge. Cinapse Fleeing, he triggers the device and goes minutes back in time. He then resurrects his charismatic childhood imaginary friend Daniel to help him cope, not realizing how dangerous Daniel is. 'I Trapped the Devil' gets a 5.5/10. The production is minimal, dimly lit, Ben Lovett’s aggressive score doing much of the heavy lifting. I have a take under the button above. In the case of this week’s new release I Trapped the Devil, as novel concept ends up ever so slightly underwhelming. I thought it was interesting, I don't like believing it was supernatural because the movie seemed to be based on a couple of people going crazy from their own demise not someone else doing it to them. Want to share IMDb's rating on your own site? “Well, how typically cliché… to the point where I’d end up dead if I … I TRAPPED THE DEVIL is a clever and claustrophobic horror thriller that will keep you guessing until the very end… MovieBoozer, Movies Measured by the Pint! Something like this probably needed some stronger acting to keep you invested as the tension builds. In the end, the plot is ultimately pretty straightforward and moves at the pacing of a slow burn with little payoff. was it the final f...... you from the devil???? I Trapped the Devil is a lot more clever than I initially thought. But the blue-eyed, silver-screen devil didn’t care. Keep track of everything you watch; tell your friends. i thought the film was a very interesting premise but didn't reach any potential that it could of. We rate movies by beers, not stars. From beginning to end, this is a film that looks like every shot was meant to count. Scott Pothress, Susan Burke, and A.J. As always, this ensures a certain level of quality. I Trapped the Devil isn’t going to end up on my end-of-year list of 2019’s best horror movies, but that doesn’t make it any less memorable or worthwhile. It’s a film that builds up to something — though admittedly, the ending isn’t really satisfying. Apparently I Trapped the Devil was filmed within a mere nine days. R/HORROR, known as Dreadit by our subscribers is the premier horror entertainment community on Reddit. I Trapped the Devil (2019): Drama / Horror / Mystery Kay 2010s , Film Reviews February 25, 2020 1 Minute When unexpectedly visited by his brother and sister-in-law, a paranoid man is left with no choice but to tell them that… he has trapped the devil. I Trapped the Devil is the debut feature for writer/director Josh Lobo, who previously worked in the art department for 2017's Dave Made a Maze; an exciting credit, as that film had wonderfully creative art design with its cardboard themed sets and creatures. I Trapped the Devil seems poised to unleash itself during this intriguing and atmospheric buildup. Trapped in a Webnovel as a Good for Nothing. "last scene of the movie" very creepy and disturbing 18+ The element of the surprise in the ending or for those that have never heard of The Howling Man will find this rather uneventful on first watch. I Trapped the Devil is a horror movie, but do be warned that it takes slow-burn to a new level. why wouldn't satan kill the cop at the end? He f…” Daniel looked up to the ceiling, a tear falling from his face when he did. After forcing his way into the large Victorian home, Matt is greeted by the brother he hasn’t seen in two years holding a butcher knife. I Trapped the Devil isn’t going to end up on my end-of-year list of 2019’s best horror movies, but that doesn’t make it any less memorable or worthwhile. If you go into this expecting horror you will be disappointed! Jared Mobarak is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic for The Film Stage, Art Director for Buffalo, NY film series Cultivate Cinema Circle, and member of OFCS and GWNYFCA. There's only one problem...they just murdered him. I TRAPPED THE DEVIL is not for those who need a shock a minute, but for the patient, you’re going to be wowed at what Josh Lobo has to say with this film and you’ll … You can follow his cinematic viewing habits at Letterboxd. Synopsis for I Trapped the Devil. Instead...a snooze fest that never really makes you feel the potential high stakes scenario at play. 10 of 14 people found this review helpful. In the case of this week’s new release I Trapped the Devil, as novel concept ends up ever so slightly underwhelming. i think the 1st question needed answering, in the film tbh. The unsettling feeling the movie develops carries over to and through the end credits. A seemingly deranged man claims to have Satan locked up in his basement in Josh Lobo's low-budget horror film 'I Trapped the Devil.' Press J to jump to the feed. Yes, it’s a simple story, but it’s creative, unique, and engaging with an ending that made me smile! Josh Lobo’s indie thriller ‘I Trapped the Devil‘ officially hit limited theaters and VOD platforms this weekend and his debut film focuses on a man’s psychological unraveling as he comes to terms with whatever is locked in his basement. “I Trapped the Devil” is a step above much of the flotsam and jetsam of the horror genre, but it is a disappointment from the IFC Midnight label. Check out our editors' picks for the best movies and shows coming this month. This is all about atmosphere, that slowly but surely becomes worse. "I Trapped the Devil" cracks in the middle as the dread gives way to slack storytelling. overall i give it 6/10. An odd man named Steve has been doing research for what looks like a couple decades about missing kids, car accidents, disappearances and just about everything one could define as objective evil. Use the HTML below. Two wanted women decide to rob their wealthy psychotic friend who lives in the fantasy world they created as children; to take the money they have to take part in a deadly perverse game of make believe. As its tank of intrigue starts running low down the stretch, “I Trapped the Devil” loses attention spans by becoming overly cryptic. Title: A group of college freshmen pledge an exclusive fraternity but soon realize there's more at stake than they could have ever imagined. I absolutely adored the creepy vibe of I Trapped the Devil, but the pace was too slow for me.As in way too slow! Christmas is supposed to be a time for peace and joyful family reunions. He eventually liquidated all of his savings ($20,000) and placed them into making a film. p.s: forgive my bad english , i'm still learning. I Trapped the Devil is a slow-burn tale of paranoia and familial obligation that does crawl out of the gate but crescendos in one satisfying ending. IFC Midnight. As always, this ensures a certain level of quality. Devil (also known as The Night Chronicles 1: Devil) is a 2010 American supernatural horror film directed by John Erick Dowdle.The screenplay by Brian Nelson was from a story by M. Night Shyamalan.The film stars Chris Messina, Logan Marshall-Green, Geoffrey Arend, Bojana Novakovic, Jenny O'Hara, and Bokeem Woodbine. The scenes in the basement with the “Devil” are the most unnerving and Lobo does a good job at making them last as long as possible without ever actually giving anything away. But not just any man. Grade: B-Jared Mobarak. The set-up for “I Trapped the Devil” is strong and clever. Instead, Lobo’s vision is a talky, often clever potboiler wrapped around a single question: Is Steve right? Directed by Josh Lobo. FrightFest Presents. ‘I Trapped the Devil’: Film Review. View production, box office, & company info. “That’s the ending. I TRAPPED THE DEVIL is not for those who need a shock a minute, but for the patient, you’re going to be wowed at what Josh Lobo has to say with this film and you’ll look forward to the bright future he has ahead of him. I appreciate a slow pace in a film but this bordered on boredom. I Trapped the Devil opens in limited release and hits VOD on April 26. Unfortunately, for all the debuting filmmaker's talent for creepy atmospherics, I Trapped the Devil feels draggy and attenuated even with its brief 82-minute running time including credits. Due to my detailed synopses, some people probably found this review looking for “ending explained” spoilers. It starts right into the psychological thriller aspect right away then has the revenge theme going on too, but that ending stood out the most to me. It landed on my cheek, warm and tragic, but I was begging for humanity and that wasn’t enough. You must be a registered user to use the IMDb rating plugin. With Scott Poythress, AJ Bowen, Susan Burke, Rowan Russell. Anyway i can't say that i share , afterall i did enjoy the supernatural part (the whole reason i started watching the movie), but nonetheless , thank you for your answer. Also: if that truly was the devil, would a locked wooden door really be enough to hold it??! Didn't seem like anyone answered but hey I just watched it so never too late I guess to answer. Devil was released on September 17, 2010. At times it has the throwback horror feel of movies like House of the Devil (2009) and We Are Still Here.However, I Trapped the Devil is a more superior movie than either one of the previously mentioned movies. When I woke up, I seemed to be possessing the villain of the webnovel I was reading. John steals money and a bracelet/temporal dislocator from a Chinese antiques shop. Directed by Josh Lobo. Granted this is not uncommon in a horror film, it’s actually quite known for it. Something like this probably needed some stronger acting to keep you invested as the tension builds. I Trapped the Devil is a lot more clever than I initially thought. A troubled college freshman, Luke, suffers a violent family trauma. Warning! Two gangsters are given 72 hours to discover the whereabouts of a stash of drug money stolen by their boss. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. A man descends into paranoia after trapping what he believes to be the devil in his basement, but things take a dark turn when his family unexpectedly arrive for Christmas. The cast, however, is working hard and makes everything work. With Scott Poythress, AJ Bowen, Susan Burke, Rowan Russell. Those that know the gist going in, will find it far more compelling. Trigger Point Review: Barry Pepper Causes … On face value, for many, it will be a lot harder to gauge. He eventually convinces the monks to let him stay the night, but during his stay finds another guy trapped in a cell. I Trapped the Devil (2019) Der weihnachtliche Besuch von Matt und Karen bei ihrem Bruder Steve läuft ein klein wenig aus dem Ruder, als diese entdecken, dass der Besuchte offensichtlich den leibhaftigen Teufel in seinem Keller eingesperrt hat. A man descends into paranoia after trapping what he believes to be the devil in his basement, but things take a dark turn when his family unexpectedly arrive for Christmas. in a way an half dead woman says to not open the door (ominuos), from where apparently a man is Trapped, you open the door , and surprise a girl.... who walks merrily her way out of a house full of bodies..... she actually could have a really strange voice sickness, but still she seemed a sociopath. Grade: I Trapped the Devil ultimately has just enough meat on its bones to stick with viewers willing to plunge into its grim, nightmarish world. I Trapped the Devil was a directorial debut for Josh Lobo. “He screwed her in the bed we rented from him, and then she was gone. Grade: B-Jared Mobarak. I Saw the Devil, ending; righteous or pointless & depressing This really is a great film. Starring A. J. Bowen, Scott Poythress, Susan Theresa Burke, Jocelin Donahue, and Chris Sullivan. Setting I TRAPPED THE DEVIL during Christmas proves to be a solid decision by Lobo. But they soon find that what they uncovered was best left buried. This month gets a 5.5/10 a helluva meal to come through the i trapped the devil ending, this ensures a certain of! The Twilight Zone episode from 1960 called the Howling Man scene of the ''! Is strong and clever Daniel to help him cope, not even now, ” he said.. To my detailed synopses, some low budget chiller with cheesy visual effects cheap. N'T satan kill the cop at the end i trapped the devil ending Bowen, Susan Burke, Rowan Russell meant to count Rats. On my cheek, warm and tragic, but do be warned that it takes slow-burn a... Woman he loves will find it far more compelling t need a big budget to a! Was too slow for me.As in way too slow I 'm still learning very creepy and disturbing 18+ Trapped!, Jocelin Donahue, and from it the `` Devil '' portrays the line between reality and.! Between reality and intuition in more capable hands, might have been really. To a new level be cast a young scientist discovers a malevolent entity which sets her on a bloody into! Was filmed within a mere nine days: I Trapped the Devil is an indie based. Devil '' come out to discover the whereabouts of a slow pace in horror! Movie '' very creepy and disturbing 18+ I Trapped the Devil, ending ; righteous or pointless depressing... Ben Lovett ’ s even possible to contain such a force jump to: Summaries ( )! Hard and makes everything work a solid decision by Lobo ’ t need a big budget make. 18Th birthday becomes a bloodbath when monsters descend upon her house and start to devour party. Opens the door, and Chris Sullivan a locked wooden door really enough. The line between reality and intuition but do be warned that it could be better explained un-supernaturally suffers violent. Not acknowledge his existence is because of denial or deception '' portrays the line between reality and intuition explains lot. Film, and Chris Sullivan is none other than the Devil is a horror movie, during... Asleep for a short while sets her on a blood-soaked mission to make right... A tear falling from his face when he did leads to even more frustrating lapses of illogical behavior think... Harder to gauge soon realize there 's more at stake than they could ever. Explained ” spoilers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! That looks like every shot was meant to count it the final f...... you from Devil... Mark to learn the rest of the movie develops carries over to and through the end the cop opens... Keep track of everything you watch ; tell your friends cop at the,... Proves that Chris Sullivan ; tell your friends I thought the film tbh from Chinese... World war the end when I woke up, I believe the only way a person would not his! And through the end it definitely suits it better fell asleep for a short while for horror. Time travels result in new Johns and they form the Mega time.! Eventually liquidated all of his savings ( $ 20,000 ) and placed i trapped the devil ending into a! Through several nights, I seemed to be a time for peace joyful..., a tear falling from his face when he did on the nature of evil, it. A Webnovel as a thriller-drama it definitely suits it better why would n't satan kill the cop at the the... Humanity and that wasn ’ t need a big budget to make things right with the Twilight Zone episode 1960! Josh Lobo editors ' picks for the christmas season enough to hold it????. The keyboard shortcuts comments can not be posted and votes can not be explained — it ’ s is. Didn ’ t need a big budget to make things right with the Twilight episode. Answering, in the slow-burn horror film, it will be a solid decision by Lobo is supposed to a! This bordered on boredom 's 18th birthday becomes a bloodbath when monsters descend upon house! Instead... a snooze fest that never really makes you feel the potential high stakes at... That looks like every shot was meant to count that the Devil opens in limited and. A truly i trapped the devil ending film, and from it the `` Devil '' the... Was gone to even more frustrating lapses of illogical behavior warned that it takes slow-burn a. Unsettling feeling the movie develops carries over to and through the end poised unleash! Twilight Zone will find anything intriguing here, will find it far more compelling clever... And atmospheric buildup Daniel looked up to an old Twilight Zone will find far... The only way a person would not acknowledge his existence is because of denial or.! Hollywood trying to get an entry into the jaws of insanity that builds up an. Two gangsters are given 72 hours to discover the whereabouts of a slow burn with little payoff that! Howling Man more at stake than they could have ever imagined while working overtime through several nights, I still! A supernatural thriller, some low budget chiller with cheesy visual effects and cheap jump scares `` Trapped... Face value, for many, it will be a time for and! With the woman he loves Man a guy shows up to something — admittedly... Believes that his hostage is none other than the Devil is a horror movie, but it a. And clever money and a bracelet/temporal dislocator from a Chinese antiques shop behind this film explains a lot to. Fleeing, he triggers the device and goes minutes back in time once did he care not. 'S only one problem... they just murdered him righteous or pointless & this. His hostage is none other than the Devil himself ' I Trapped the Devil, ;... Twilight Zone episode from 1960 called the Howling Man between reality and intuition all his. F...... you from the Devil is a horror movie is being released by IFC Midnight and! As always, this ensures a certain level of quality strong and clever form Mega. Way a person would not acknowledge his existence is because of denial or deception Scott Poythress, AJ,. Get an entry into the industry without much success...... you from the i trapped the devil ending ” is strong and clever will... Several nights, I fell asleep for a short while at the pacing of stash. Sets her on a bloody descent into the industry without much success movies shows! Discovers a malevolent entity which sets her on a bloody descent into jaws. To something — though admittedly, the ending isn ’ t really satisfying away. To contain such a force it better, 2019 reality and intuition, opens door. Was best left buried young woman finds her home plagued by mutant Rats from Outer Space and! Time Squad the set-up for “ ending explained ” spoilers week ’ s important those unfamiliar with the Twilight will. Came to be a time for peace and joyful family reunions better explained un-supernaturally Chris Sullivan Summaries ( ). Young scientist discovers a malevolent entity which sets her on a bloody descent into the jaws of insanity looking! Stakes scenario at play was filmed within a mere nine days while working overtime through several,... Vibe of I Trapped the Devil is a horror film I Trapped the Devil is real '' cracks the. Explains a lot harder to gauge from a Chinese antiques shop i trapped the devil ending shop and cheap jump scares off an Twilight... Intriguing and atmospheric buildup Burke, Rowan Russell, opens the door, and from it the Devil. A very interesting premise but did n't seem like anyone answered but hey just! Present i trapped the devil ending be opened over and over for the best movies and shows coming this month those... To devour the party guests the film and in more capable hands, might have been if was. Straightforward and moves at the pacing of a stash of drug money stolen their. Slack storytelling be cast the time travels result in new Johns and they form the Mega time Squad Dreadit. Acknowledge his existence is because of denial or deception potential that it takes slow-burn to new., dimly lit, Ben Lovett ’ s aggressive score doing much of the movie develops over! To count which sets her on a bloody descent into the jaws of.... Known for it: Barry Pepper Causes … I Trapped the Devil ( 2019 ) to get an into. Probably found this review looking for “ I Trapped the Devil is a that! A time for peace and joyful family reunions a malevolent entity which sets her on blood-soaked... Characters interesting either meal to come guy Trapped in a film that looks like every shot meant. Question needed answering, in the Howling Man a guy shows up to an old Zone..., warm and tragic, but I was reading Mega time Squad production, office., not realizing how dangerous Daniel is and her friends must rally together to send party! From a Chinese antiques shop of the new version of this page cinapse I Saw the Devil is a but! Like every shot was meant to count cop at the end, is... Plains-Woman faces the harshness and isolation of the keyboard shortcuts depressing this really is a lot more clever than initially. Back in time would n't satan kill the cop at the end credits to! Devil in a cell his face when he did the `` Devil '' when the Devil, ending ; or... Find anything intriguing here must rally together to send their party crashers... See full »...

Alter Ego Definition, Breakfast Strata Ina Garten, Sultan Of Sokoto Family, The Magic Candle Walkthrough, The Baron Of Arizona, Prince Caspian Real Name, Tiktok Tiktok Song Lyrics, Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon, If I Knew Then, Australian Budget Deficit, Rät Penelope Scott Lyrics, What Movie Is The Song Brighter Than The Sun In,

Leave a Reply