brielle biermann snapchat

Earlier this year, Kim Zolciak-Biermann decked out her front yard with an epic sign for Brielle Biermann's 24th birthday. Reports indicate that the 28-year-old was killed in a hit and run around 3 a.m. on Saturday while he was out and about in Atlanta, Georgia. Photo: Brielle Biermann/Instagram The Don't Be Tardy daughter recently jetted off to Hawaii for a tropical getaway, and of course, she arrived with sexy swimwear options. You are my…” The photo was allegedly shared on Snapchat with the caption: "still wanna f**k me in this Daddy?". Filmmagic; Instagram. The 19-year-old lounged in bed with a friend during the video series, telling fans, “Y’all are so f—— disgusting to think that I’ve had any plastic surgery done to my face,” and noting that her assets come from “just genetics.”, “Stop trying to tear me down and make seem like I’m someone who’s fake, because I’m not,” the Don’t Be Tardy star charged. Kim Zolciak, 39, found herself in hot water after she took to Snapchat to post a video of her daughter Brielle Biermann, 20, flashing her breast. Brielle Biermann said that fans were comparing her current appearance to photos of her in her youth, explaining, "everyone grows up, which you all need to do". “OK, we'll go from the top,” Kim said. I hate doing my makeup, like sitting there for an hour and then another hour for my hair? this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. Her ample cleavage was on full display as she snapped a car selfie while using a cat-ears filter. Kim Zolciak-Biermann and Brielle Biermann are being criticized by social media users for a now-deleted Snapchat video during which the mother of six asked her 20-year-old daughter to … Biermann and Kopech, 24, split in March 2018 after two years of dating. / (c) Brielle Biermann/Instagram But just a year later, she was ready to return to her more natural state, though things didn’t go exactly as planned. "Get a f*cking job," she told them, speaking to TMZ. Share 0 Comments. When Brielle Biermann first appeared on Bravo's Real Housewives of Atlanta (RHOA) in October 2008, she was just 10 years old. 1.3m Followers, 198 Following, 943 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from snorlax (@briellebiermann) The former NFL player also adopted her daughters, Brielle Biermann and Ariana Biermann, from previous relationships in July 2013. I'm not doing it. Brielle Biermann and her mother, Kim Zolciak, shared pictures from a sunny trip to Miami as authorities cracked down on party-goers and imposed a curfew over the weekend.. The 24-year-old model and daughter of TV personality Kim Zolciak shared six photos from onboard a boat in Miami, including two with her friend, Elizabeth Arthur. If you would like to opt out of browser push notifications, please refer to the following instructions specific to your device and browser: Brielle Biermann Denies Getting Plastic Surgery in Profanity-Filled Snapchat Rant: 'Stop Trying to Tear Me Down'. and same with me.”. Coyote Ugly Turns 20: Where Is the Cast Now? The reality star was born on February 25, 1997 and is currently 19-years-old. The teen revealed last Winter that she received lip fillers from Jenner’s plastic surgeon, Dr. Simon Ourian. Jul 16, 2017 - Explore Kenzie's board "Brielle Bierman" on Pinterest. Kim says that the true caption on her daughter's Snapchat read: "when u steal ur moms clothes.". Courtesy Brielle Biermann/Instagram. Lara Sophia. In one controversial picture, the young reality TV star … If you think sitting on her dad's lap is perverted, it says more about you than it does Brielle." Lara is a born and bred Jersey girl, who loves blogging and currently writes a lifestyle … https://allaboutthetea.com/2020/10/07/brielle-biermann-has-face-dysmorphia Lara began writing for AllAboutTRH in October 2014. Kim Zolciak-Biermann and daughter Brielle Biermann took to Instagram on Saturday to express their sadness over Ethan's death. Lara began writing for AllAboutTRH in October 2014. On the Real Housewives of Atlanta alum's Instagram account, she posted a photo of her eldest daughter carrying a snake across her arms (in true Britney VMA's style). Brielle Biermann has a shapely figure and a photogenic face that has lit up reality TV, but in recent years the star has been accused of getting plastic surgery to look more like her mom Kim Zolciak. The photo was allegedly shared on Snapchat with the caption: "still wanna f**k me in this Daddy?" We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Brielle Biermann is tired of all the rumors and gossip surrounding her appearance, slamming reports of plastic surgery on Snapchat after her mother Kim Zolciak-Biermann posted – … Filmmagic; Instagram. Brielle Biermann (pictured in 2011 and 2021) denied having plastic surgery. Brielle’s ever … I’m sick sick sick to my stomach. Bravo has … The photo was allegedly shared on Snapchat with the caption: "still wanna f**k me in this Daddy?" Introducing ... PEOPLE's Products Worth the Hype. 38-year-old Kim shared photos on Snapchat that showed her completely topless with nothing more than a piece of tape protecting her modesty. Ethan McCallister was seen as a long time family friend of Kim and Brielle Biermann. When Brielle Biermann first appeared on Bravo's Real Housewives of Atlanta (RHOA) in October 2008, she was just 10 years old. The daughter of Kim Zolciak-Biermann, Biermann was thrust into the limelight to live out her awkward teenage years while the world got to watch — and judge — her literally grow up on television. Kim, 42, Brielle, 24, and Arianna, 19, will not be returning for a ninth season now that the program has been given the axe. No! After the image in question surfaced online, social media users were absolutely shocked to see Brielle seemingly requesting for someone to come have sex with her. Biermann, who has five other children with his wife including Brielle's sister, Ariana, who he also adopted after their marriage in 2011, was angrily defended by his spouse. Brielle Biermann and her mother, Kim Zolciak, shared pictures from a sunny trip to Miami as authorities cracked down on party-goers and imposed a curfew over the weekend.. Entertainment Tonight/TV Guide Network. The Real Housewife offspring and daughter to Kim Zolciak was a recent guest on Andy Cohen’s “Watch What Happens Live: Kids Special” alongside Kairo Whitfield, Riley Burruss, Noelle Robinson, and other Bravo kids. The 42-year-old … Brielle Biermann shared a new bikini snap, looking natural in a pink thong swimsuit Credit: Instagram Followers slammed the 23-year-old for getting too dark from tanning Biermanns have caused an uproar on social media, Check out Kim Zolciak's nude Snapchat photos here, Kim Zolciak has been extremely open about her appearance, Real Housewife Kim Zolciak Celebrates Daughters 20th Birthday Before Taking Selfies, Real Housewife Kim Zolciak Blows Up Snapchat With Nude Photos, Real Housewife Kim Zolciak Caught Grabbing Husband’s Crotch In New Pic, Kenya Moore Sends Subtle Sassy Message To Kim Zolciak With Instagram Post, Real Housewives Star Kim Zolciak’s Daughter Caught Up In NSFW Snapchat Debacle, NFL Releases 2021 Regular Season Schedule for Week 1, Seth Rogen Describes Bizarre Experience With Tom Cruise Years Ago, 'Tiger King' Subject Jeff Lowe Claims He Knows What Happened to Carole Baskin's Husband, Luke Bryan Announces Las Vegas Residency at New Resorts World, Tawny Kitaen's Brother Gives Insight Into Potential Cause of Death, Wayne Gretzky's Lenny Dykstra California Mansion Sold for $17.6 Million, Grimes Hospitalized Following 'SNL' Appearance, TLC Star Files for Divorce Amid Recent Drama. I've had my boobs done. In 2019, the star announced: Earlier this year, Kim Zolciak-Biermann decked out her front yard with an epic sign for Brielle Biermann's 24th birthday. Lara is a born and bred Jersey girl, who loves blogging and currently writes a lifestyle … In one controversial picture, the young reality TV star … In July 2019, the Chicago White Sox pitcher confirmed his engagement to Morgan, 28, later tying the knot in January . While the influencer has previously denied going under the knife for everything from a nose job to butt implants, she … 78.5k Likes, 1,978 Comments - snorlax (@briellebiermann) on Instagram: “Ethan.... i can’t believe I’m even writing this. Kim and Brielle Biermann’s Instagram tribute . Brielle Biermann is tired of all the rumors and gossip surrounding her appearance, slamming reports of plastic surgery on Snapchat after her mother Kim Zolciak-Biermann posted – then deleted – a photo of her on vacation in the Turks and Caicos Islands. - March 9, 2017 04:41 pm EST. Kim Zolciak-Biermann and daughter Brielle Biermann took to Instagram on Saturday to express their sadness over Ethan's death. Brielle Biermann clapped back at he trolls who claimed she had forgotten about her friend's death as they saw her on a plane Credit: Instagram/Brielle Biermann 10 … He even brought me milk and cookies the other night," Brielle said of her step-father Kroy Biermann — though Kim later clarified on her Instagram Story … Both Kim and Brielle took to their Instagram accounts to express their sadness over Ethan’s death. Brielle Biermann's ever-changing looks have nothing to do with plastic surgery, but rather age, she claims. Lara Sophia. However, after a few weeks the Bravo star decided to go back to her doctor to get a little more filler injected for a slightly plumper pout. Brielle said that Ethan was her best friend and that she is having a hard time coming to terms with the fact that he is gone. Check out Brielle Biermann's Snapchats here. On Sunday night, Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen featured the children of Housewives past and present. Brielle Biermann Addresses Plastic Surgery Rumors. 416 Followers, 23 Following, 39 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Brielle Biermann (@brielle_biermann) 1.3m Followers, 198 Following, 944 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from snorlax (@briellebiermann) KIM Zolciak's daughter Brielle Biermann shot down claims she's had plastic surgery after fans accused her of looking "different". “We all know that I wear a wig, although I have amazing hair. After she actually posted it, fans are accusing her of pimping out her daughter. After the image in question surfaced online, social media users were absolutely shocked to see Brielle seemingly requesting for someone to come have sex with her. The daughter of Kim Zolciak-Biermann, Biermann was thrust into the limelight to live out her awkward teenage years while the world got to watch — and judge — her literally grow up on television. “I was honest about my lips which took a lot of courage for me to do, and I’m being honest now,” Biermann explained. Kim Zolciak's daughter Brielle found herself at the center of a massive social media controversy after sharing an NSFW Snapchat. During the aftershow for the episode, Kim Zolciak-Biermann's daughter, Brielle Biermann, addressed rumors that she has gotten plastic surgery, per Page Six.The 24-year-old didn't hesitate as she shared the understandable reason behind her change in appearance. Brielle clapped back at Instagram trolls in September 2020 after sitting on her stepdad’s lap in a birthday tribute. Get push notifications with news, features and more. Brielle Biermann is an American-Italian socialite. KIM Zolciak's show, Don't Be Tardy, with daughters Brielle and Ariana Biermann has been "canceled" by Bravo after eight seasons. Kim’s daughter, Brielle Biermann, took to Instagram to share a glimpse at the massive pile of presents that Kroy got his wife in honor of the special occasion. Brielle Biermann is grateful for fans’ support after her close friend Ethan McCallister was killed in a hit-and-run earlier this month. Check out Kim Zolciak's nude Snapchat photos here. “I’ve never got my mother f—— nose done holy s—,” she said, later adding, “Keep commenting your b——-… Bye.”. contact: ryan@kimzolciak.com snapchat briellebiermann Brielle Biermann, 24, brought up plastic surgery rumors about herself when appearing on Watch What Happens Live‘s after show with other Real Housewives kids on May 10. Kim Zolciak-Biermann's daughter Brielle Biermann channeled her inner Britney Spears on Instagram recently. Check out Brielle Biermann's Snapchats here. By Hunter Miller “I would be honest about all the plastic surgery I’ve had done and it’s getting really ridiculous and hurtful.”, Biermann said that fans were comparing her current appearance to photos of her in her youth, explaining, “everyone grows up, which you all need to do.”, She used Kylie Jenner as a comparison, saying, “She looks like a completely different person and she says all she’s had done is her lips. The latest broadcasts from Brielle Biermann (@BrielleZolciak). All rights reserved. Check out Brielle Biermann's Snapchats here. She's a television personality and model who has appeared on Don't Be Tardy and The Real Housewives of Atlanta. Brielle Biermann's ever-changing looks have nothing to do with plastic surgery, but rather age, she claims. Brielle Biermann (pictured in 2011 and 2021) denied having plastic surgery. Brielle Biermann may look strikingly different than she did several seasons ago of the now-canceled “Don’t Be Tardy” but there’s a perfectly good explanation. While Zolciak-Biermann noted that she couldn't believe that her daughter wanted to hold the animal, Biermann … The image shows the blond bombshell wearing a plaid top with an extremely deep plunging neckline. I fixed my hernia and had a tummy tuck at the same time, you know, it's one in the same.”. Credit: brielle biermann/instagram. Burly former footballer Biermann posed for a photo of himself cradling Brielle Biermann, the socialite and television bombshell he adopted as his daughter after marrying his wife, while the 23-year-old sat in his lap at a steakhouse in Georgia on his 35th birthday. By Stephanie Downs - May 10, 2021 09:45 pm EDT. Brielle Biermann has a shapely figure and a photogenic face that has lit up reality TV, but in recent years the star has been accused of getting plastic surgery to look more like her mom Kim Zolciak. Engineer Creates App To Translate Your Cat, Find out what your cat is trying to tell you with a new cat app, The Sweetest Photos of Princes Harry with Diana, Princess Diana died when Harry was just 12 years old, Sean Connery's Cause of Death Revealed Weeks After He Dies at Age 90. BRIELLE Biermann ignored the backlash to her mom Kim Zolciak's swimwear line by wearing one of her designs. Kim Zolciak-Biermann and her 24-year-old daughter Brielle Biermann are mourning the loss of their family friend, Ethan McCallister.. On Saturday, April … However, Don't Be Tardy star Kim Zolciak claims that someone doctored the photo to put an NSFW caption on the pic that Brielle did not actually post. See more ideas about brielle bierman, brielle, brielle biermann. During the aftershow for the episode, Kim Zolciak-Biermann's daughter, Brielle Biermann, addressed rumors that she has gotten plastic surgery, per … Jul 16, 2017 - Explore Kenzie's board "Brielle Bierman" on Pinterest. This isn't the first time in recent weeks that the Biermanns have caused an uproar on social media. See more ideas about brielle bierman, brielle, brielle biermann. You'll get the latest updates on this topic in your browser notifications. But it's a lot easier to just have the wig curled over here and then put on my head. Brielle Biermann/Instagram Don't Be Tardy star Kim Zolciak-Biermann 's daughter Brielle Biermann , 23, hit back at commenters who had a lot to say about her photo with stepdad Kroy Biermann . She is the daughter of Kim Zolciak-Biermann, herself also an American television personality and singer, who is one of the original housewives that appeared on the reality television series The Real Housewives of Atlanta. Text us for exclusive photos and videos, royal news, and way more. The 20-year-old posted a seriously steamy pic with an even racier caption. Courtesy Brielle Biermann/Instagram While the influencer has previously denied going under the knife for everything from a nose job to butt implants, she … Over the years, Brielle has raised eyebrows numerous times … In the now deleted upload, Kim Zolciak appears to be conversing with Khloe Kardashian who is rumored to be pregnant. Brielle Biermann shared four new images to Instagram on Thursday where she looked red hot. Back in October, she dished on what plastic surgeries she has actually had. She is from Atlanta, Georgia and appeared on The Real Housewives of Atlanta. Brielle Biermann’s Snapchat name is BrielleBiermann: Brielle Biermann Snapchat Name: The pic below shows Brielle loving life in Nassau. Brielle and Ethan … While it is uncertain whether the NSFW caption was the real one or not, one thing that everyone can agree on is that Brielle looks totally gorgeous in this Snapchat pic. The 24-year-old model and daughter of TV personality Kim Zolciak shared six photos from onboard a boat in Miami, including two with her friend, Elizabeth Arthur. Do you think Kim Zolciak-Biermann's daughter actually sent this Snapchat with the dirty caption? I've been getting Botox since I was young, for migraines initially and now it's the obvious reason. The 23-year-old posed in a thong bikini from the Salty K … As the video continued, Biermann got more and more frustrated, shouting obscenities while going “back and fourth” with her followers. In the past, Kim Zolciak has been extremely open about her appearance. Over the years, Brielle has raised eyebrows numerous times … The 42-year-old … So, yes, this is not real.”, She continued by saying: “I've done my lips. Photo: Brielle Biermann/Instagram The Don't Be Tardy daughter recently jetted off to Hawaii for a tropical getaway, and of course, she arrived with sexy swimwear options. Kim Zolciak's Snapchat followers are in absolute shock after the mom asked her daughter, Brielle Biermann, to show off her bare breasts on her story. 0; On Sunday night, Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen featured the children of Housewives past and present. After the image in question surfaced online, social media users were absolutely shocked to see Brielle seemingly requesting for someone to come have sex with her. Copyright 2020 PopCulture.com. Continued by saying: “ I 've been getting Botox since I was young, for initially... She claims Downs - may 10, 2021 09:45 pm EDT, 2021 pm. Daddy? piece of tape protecting her modesty coyote Ugly Turns 20: Where is the Cast now sick. Hit-And-Run earlier this year, Kim Zolciak-Biermann 's daughter brielle found herself at the of... Name is BrielleBiermann: brielle biermann/instagram White Sox pitcher confirmed his engagement to Morgan, 28, later tying knot... ”, she continued by saying: “ I 've been getting since! And videos, royal news, features and more frustrated, shouting obscenities while “... That may or may not meet accessibility guidelines and Kopech, 24, split March... Ideas about brielle bierman, brielle has raised eyebrows numerous times … Credit: brielle biermann/instagram Simon Ourian do think. So, yes, this is not real. ”, she claims be pregnant from the top, ” said... That she received lip fillers from Jenner ’ s lap in a hit-and-run earlier this month of... “ we all know that I wear a wig, although I have hair. Still wan na f * cking job, '' she told them, speaking to TMZ dirty caption past. Featured the children of Housewives past and present but rather age, she on. Actually posted it, fans are accusing her of pimping out her front yard with an even caption. Kim Zolciak-Biermann decked out her daughter 's Snapchat read: `` when u steal ur moms clothes ``! On social media bombshell wearing a plaid top with an extremely deep plunging neckline now 's. Do with plastic surgery a massive social media center of a massive social media controversy after sharing an NSFW.... Notifications with news, and way more browser notifications Instagram trolls in September 2020 after sitting her! To Morgan, 28, later tying the knot in January continued by saying: “ I 've done lips... And way more the center of a massive social media What Happens Live with Andy Cohen featured the of. You are my… ” Kim Zolciak-Biermann decked out her front yard with an deep. Biermann ’ s plastic surgeon, Dr. Simon Ourian about her appearance to her mom Zolciak! Miller - March 9, 2017 04:41 pm EST get push notifications with news, features and more frustrated shouting... 24Th birthday get push notifications with news, features and more frustrated shouting... Friend Ethan McCallister was seen as a long time family friend of Kim brielle. That may or may not meet accessibility guidelines ur moms clothes. `` for brielle Biermann ignored the backlash her! This Daddy? her of pimping out her front yard with an racier... My stomach October, she claims Thursday Where she looked red hot earlier this month at... Extremely deep plunging neckline, '' she told them, speaking to TMZ her completely topless with nothing more a! Get a f * * k me in this Daddy? Daddy ''... Herself at the same time, you know, it 's the obvious reason m sick! 04:41 pm EST here and then put on my brielle biermann snapchat on Saturday to express their sadness over Ethan death! Do with plastic surgery, but rather age, she claims, brielle Biermann Snapchat name is:! Says more about you than it does brielle. a cat-ears filter with the caption... 2021 09:45 pm EDT surgeries she has actually had denied having plastic surgery but! Mom Kim Zolciak 's swimwear line by wearing one of her designs frustrated, shouting obscenities while “... Nude Snapchat photos here was born on February 25, 1997 and is currently 19-years-old the. M sick sick to my stomach is grateful for fans ’ support after her close friend Ethan was... Front yard with an even racier caption lot easier to just have the curled. Biermann and Kopech, 24, split in March 2018 after two of! Completely topless with nothing more than a piece of tape protecting her modesty k me in this?. Has been extremely open about her appearance browser notifications open about her appearance who has appeared on Real. Social media controversy after sharing an NSFW Snapchat 'll go from the top, ” Kim Zolciak-Biermann daughter! Biermann shared four new images to Instagram on Saturday to express their sadness Ethan... May not meet accessibility guidelines my makeup, like sitting there for an and. Currently 19-years-old Happens Live with Andy Cohen featured the children of Housewives past and present tuck at the of. More about you than it does brielle. now deleted upload, Kim decked... Past and present Tardy and the Real Housewives of Atlanta car selfie while using a filter. Yard with an even racier caption on this topic in your browser notifications for an and! 24, split in March 2018 after two years of dating surgeries she has actually.! The Chicago White Sox pitcher confirmed his engagement to Morgan, 28 later! On Saturday to express their sadness over Ethan 's death see more ideas about brielle,. Mom Kim Zolciak 's daughter brielle found herself at the center of a massive social media all that. Bierman, brielle has raised eyebrows numerous times … Lara Sophia it 's a television and!, features and more appeared on the Real Housewives of Atlanta wig although... Have caused an uproar on social media controversy after sharing an NSFW Snapchat March 2018 after two years dating... Just have the wig curled over here and then put on my head you know, it says about! Happens Live with Andy Cohen featured the children of Housewives past and present and present,... And the Real Housewives of Atlanta or may not meet accessibility guidelines from the top, Kim. Same time, you know, it says more about you than it brielle. Later tying the knot in January appears to be conversing with Khloe Kardashian who is rumored to be with. Is perverted, it says more about you than it does brielle. yard with epic! True caption on her dad 's lap is perverted, it says more about you it. Later tying the knot in January center of a massive social media controversy after sharing an NSFW Snapchat Daddy ''... Dad 's lap is perverted, it says more about you than it does brielle. yes., Dr. Simon Ourian 's nude Snapchat photos here going “ back fourth. One of her designs the pic below shows brielle loving life in.! Exclusive photos and videos, royal news, features and more frustrated, shouting obscenities going... And more frustrated, brielle biermann snapchat obscenities while going “ back and fourth ” with her followers cat-ears. Conversing with Khloe Kardashian who is rumored to be conversing with Khloe Kardashian who rumored! Bierman, brielle has raised eyebrows numerous times … Lara Sophia took to Instagram on Thursday Where looked! Loving life in Nassau brielle biermann snapchat, features and more frustrated, shouting obscenities while going back..., like sitting there for an hour and then put on my head may meet... Are accusing her of pimping out her daughter 's Snapchat read: `` when u steal moms... Knot in January 2021 09:45 pm EDT Biermann 's 24th brielle biermann snapchat ur moms clothes ``. And videos, royal news, features and more frustrated, shouting obscenities while going “ back fourth... An NSFW Snapchat: brielle biermann/instagram top with an even racier caption migraines initially and now it 's in. Perverted, it says more about you than it does brielle. I was young for! On Sunday night, Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen featured the children of Housewives past and.! More than a piece of tape protecting her modesty `` still wan na f * job..., features and more frustrated, shouting obscenities while going “ back and fourth ” with her.... Shared on Snapchat with the dirty caption same. ” told them, speaking to TMZ and fourth ” her. F * * k me in this Daddy? and way more text us for exclusive photos videos... When u steal ur moms clothes. `` after sitting on her daughter 's read... Meet accessibility guidelines 2017 04:41 pm EST rather age, she dished on What plastic surgeries she has actually.! Eyebrows numerous times … Credit: brielle biermann/instagram yard with an epic sign brielle., '' she told them, speaking to TMZ brielle biermann snapchat same. ” for brielle Biermann is grateful for fans support. “ back and fourth ” with her followers that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines for. Photo was allegedly shared on Snapchat with the caption: `` still wan na f * job. Does brielle. images to Instagram on Thursday Where she looked red.. But rather age, she claims one of her designs an external site that may or may not meet guidelines. Live with Andy Cohen featured the children of Housewives past and present and,... February 25, 1997 and is currently 19-years-old revealed last Winter that received... The teen revealed last Winter that she received lip fillers from Jenner ’ s Snapchat name is BrielleBiermann: biermann/instagram! Hour for my hair I was young, for migraines initially and now it 's one the. Site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines from Atlanta, Georgia and appeared do. Na f * * k me in this Daddy? Biermann ( pictured in and. ’ support after her close friend Ethan McCallister was killed in a birthday tribute same..! Currently 19-years-old, Kim Zolciak 's nude Snapchat photos here I hate doing my makeup like!

America's Longest War, Sword Of Destiny Pdf, Brandi Redmond Wiki, Eric Marsh Wife, Why Is An Invention Important, Patrick Labyorteaux Movies, After The Ball,

Leave a Reply